Traveller Whiskey Blend No 40 Review
Overview: Traveller Whiskey is a collaboration between country music artist Chris Stapleton and Sazerac / Buffalo Trace, with Harlen Wheatley — Buffalo Trace’s master distiller — as the technical mind behind it. The backstory goes like this: Stapleton and Wheatley sampled 50 different blends and settled on number 40 as the right one. Hence the name.
This is not a straight whiskey. That’s worth understanding up front. Without the “straight” designation, there’s no age statement requirement, no mashbill disclosure, no distillation proof ceiling, no minimum barrel aging period, and no restrictions on blending components or additives. Buffalo Trace states that no neutral grain spirits are included in the blend, which is a meaningful claim given how much blended American whiskey uses NGS as a base. But beyond that, the label tells you nothing about what’s inside. At 90 proof and a price point designed for wide retail distribution, the working assumption is that Sazerac is building a well-pour product with recognizable branding — which is a legitimate business, just not the same thing as buying a single barrel bourbon.
How I Found It: This came in as a club allocation — my whiskey club pulled it, and I received a bottle as part of the allocation. I don’t often pursue blended American whiskeys, but the Buffalo Trace connection and the Stapleton name made me curious enough to give it a fair evaluation. At this price point the downside risk is limited either way.
Age: NAS (No Age Statement)
Proof: 90 (45% ABV)
Mashbill: Undisclosed blend

Nose: Subtle, and it demands patience to get anything out of it. At 90 proof there’s minimal ethanol presence, which is fine, but there’s also a distinct absence of the classic bourbon notes you’d expect from a Buffalo Trace product. Faint oak and a medley of light fruits — apples, grapes, honeydew melon, cantaloupe. It’s pleasant enough, but undemanding. Generic fruit salad is the honest description. You’re not going to sit there and puzzle it out.
Palate: This is where it earns its rating back a little. The palate pleasantly outperforms the nose — there’s a welcome viscosity that coats the mouth, and actual sweetness comes through: cherry, butterscotch, vanilla, and a faint bready note that suggests wheat is in the blend. The flavors aren’t complex, but they’re present and they work together. For a 90-proof blended whiskey with no age statement, this is more than adequate.
Finish: Short and unmemorable, which is the main limitation here. The sweetness fades quickly and there’s not much left behind. What’s interesting is that despite the underwhelming finish, I kept coming back for another sip — the palate entry is pleasant enough that the cycle continues even when the follow-through isn’t there. That’s either well-engineered drinkability or just low-grade compulsion. Maybe both.
Who This Is Actually For
The honest assessment: Traveller is engineered for a specific use case, and it’s not the neat-pour enthusiast market. At $30 and wide retail distribution, Buffalo Trace is positioning this as an accessible, approachable bottle for people who are either new to whiskey or looking for something easy to drink without thinking about it. Chris Stapleton’s name is on the label not because he’s a distiller but because his fans are a natural audience for an accessible American whiskey that doesn’t require prior experience with the category.
There’s nothing wrong with that. Not every bottle is trying to be Pappy. Traveller serves its intended audience reasonably well — it’s smooth, not challenging, and inoffensive in a way that makes it safe to share with people who aren’t whiskey drinkers. If you have someone coming over who’s not going to appreciate what’s in the rest of your collection, this is a thoughtful pour for them.
Final Thoughts: Traveller drinks like the comfortable, mildly watered-down version of something more serious. The flavors are there but they’re not fully committed — pleasant on the palate, gone too quickly on the finish. If you’re an experienced whiskey drinker this probably isn’t your bottle, and it wasn’t mine. But I finished it without complaint and I understood what it was trying to do. Won’t be on my regular list, but I’m glad to have tried it. For a newcomer to the category, it’s a decent starting point.
If You Liked This, Try…
- Larceny Small Batch — If Traveller’s approachability is the appeal but you want something with more substance, Larceny Small Batch is the honest next step. A few dollars more, actual age and mashbill transparency, better complexity, and the same basic ease of drinking.
- Wild Turkey Rare Breed — The complete opposite end of the spectrum — barrel proof, assertive, fully committed in every way Traveller isn’t. A useful contrast for understanding what “straightforward and approachable” is trading away. Worth trying both if you’re still figuring out where your preferences land.
Rating: Leave it on the Counter — Rating system explained